Bank acquisitions by credit unions have been hotter than ever in 2024, knocking on 2022’s record 16 transactions just halfway through the year.
And the banks being bought are bigger. The largest bank involved in a credit union deal last year was New Mexico’s $338 million-asset Western Heritage Bank. However, a number of target banks in 2024 exceed that in asset size. Security State Bank, which Richland, Washington-based Gesa Credit Union proposed to acquire in May, counts $606 million in assets. First Financial Northwest Bank, which Anchorage, Alaska-based Global Federal Credit Union is buying, counts $1.5 billion.
“Credit unions are the only realistic buyers that could pay cash and absorb the bank’s balance sheet from a purchase accounting standpoint,” said Jeff Cardone, a partner at Luse Gorman who served as legal counsel to Gesa in its deal.
Assets of banks being acquired by credit unions in deals proposed in 2024 total $7.21 billion as of June 4, according to S&P Global. That far surpasses the 2022 record of $5.15 billion.
Christopher Olsen, managing partner at Olsen Palmer, noted the contrast in deal activity as early as January.
“After a somewhat tepid year for community bank M&A in 2023, we are seeing momentum building for greater M&A activity in 2024 driven by a variety of factors, including a decline in interest rates and the corresponding relief in bond valuations, a recovery in bank stock valuations, and the pursuit (on the part of acquirers) or lack of (on the part of sellers) sufficient operating scale,” Olsen told Banking Dive.
Credit union-bank tie-ups are not without controversy. Independent Community Bankers of America, a trade group, has long opposed the combinations because banks and credit unions are taxed differently.
In a February post on X, formerly Twitter, the ICBA said 20% of bank acquisitions “are now by tax-subsidized credit unions, and each one increases the portion of the financial services industry exempt from [the Community Reinvestment Act] and taxation.”
While credit unions aren’t subject to the CRA — meant to fight lending discrimination, among other things — they shouldn’t be positioned as anathema to that law, the National Association of Federally-Insured Credit Unions argued.
“Among institutions that are certified Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs), there are more than twice as many credit unions than banks, demonstrating credit unions’ desire to better serve and invest in their local community,” NAFCU shared on an info sheet. “Banks, on the other hand, are closing branches at a rate of 200 branches per month, further reducing their CRA requirements.”
The ICBA has taken its plea to consumers, asking them to urge Congress to hold a hearing on credit union policy.
Cardone, though, said credit unions are becoming a bigger part of the bank M&A landscape not because of the number of deals.
“Bank-to-bank mergers are down significantly due to an uncertain economic and regulatory environment,” Cardone said. “Once the pace of bank-to-bank mergers normalizes, the percentage of credit union buyers relative to overall bank mergers will decrease.”